From a Twitter answer in 2022:

Chocolate Trinity by Publix (basically really dark, thick chocolate, similar to the discontinued Belgian Dark Chocolate ice cream by Godiva), Triple Peanut Butter Cup/Swirl, Chocolate Cherish Passion (cherries & dark chocolate), Egg Nog, Pistachio, Mint Dark Chocolate, Coconut, Coffee, probably a few I'm not thinking of right now

When I was little it was Peppermint ice cream