Retrospring is shutting down on 1st March, 2025 Read more
512
I always like your analysis, and i am kinda curious about your perspective about Dazai and Fyodor. Don't you think Dazai could be a good lesson to Fyodor? Judging from last arc were Dazai told Fyodor that unpredictable things moght change the world (or Fyodor's perfect plan). What im trying to say is what do u think about that potential? Will Fyodor learn from that??
I think what did Dazai did to him and told him will definitely be a learning experience, but I also think he'll probably very stubborn, he seems more like the type to be annoyed/angry when he gets outplayed in such a way and then frustratingly move on. It's hard to unlearn something like trust issues, the need to control everything and to see the value in the chaotic, I hope Fyodor changes a little bit but I don't expect it to be a complete 180.
Like the other question butthis one with Dazai, what do you like the most from Dazai? Or what make u liking him?
He's silly. Also I like seeing the journey of this once depressed, suicidal guy, who still is those things, finding an appreciation for the world despite how difficult it may be to live in it and seeing him help Atsushi along the way. I at least found him more easier to appreciate after reading the light novels and the manga.
Do you have any thoughts on the moment where Jouno says to Dazai 'I can hear your rage' or just Dazai's hidden anger in general if that makes sense (?) sorry if it doesn't 😭
We normally see him at his angriest, or at least the most emotional, whenever he's being reminded of his past in the port mafia and more specifically what he had done. For example in the guild arc his dislike for Yumeno after coming face-to-face with them for the first time in the years was very apparent and filled with hostility as they're probably a representative of Dazai's past mistakes (he was earlier reminded about his past being mafia black according to his records). So when Jouno points out his rage when he's being arrested due to his past crimes in the port mafia it's likely him being angered from how the worst parts of his past always seems to haunt him. Dazai is not really the type who likes to confront his past, which is understandable, and so his hidden anger stems from those reminders that makes him remember what he's been trying to move on from.
Do you think Fyodor cared about Nikolai in any way? Or in general his "friends"? People always say he just uses the people, especially things or people he cannot control. I have the feeling that he is maybe somehow scared to get too attached to others, being afraid of getting betrayed and such (for example when Sigma "left" him and sided with Dazai, you know).
I think he does, he never shows discomfort when Nikolai held his hands or when he's talking to him and he doesn't seem to actively try and distance himself from Nikolai. He also doesn't correct Dazai or seem bothered when Dazai says "you have a great friend" when Nikolai proposes the prison escape game, he even agrees with Dazai. There is also the fyolai omake though I'm not sure I'd consider that as canon, or has as much weight as the main manga. I would describe Fyodor as having a certain fondness or interest in Nikolai but currently not much more than that from what we can see.
There are likely multiple reasons why he doesn't openly reciprocate any of Nikolai's affection, such as his trust issues over the things he can't control (I think it's been pretty well established Fyodor can't control Nikolai in any way), and the fact he probably doesn't see the need for "friends" since he might not see having "friends" in his near future due to his goal that he wants to achieve.
I remember that when the Doa art for chapter 110 dropped a lot of people were surprised that Nikolai is using his ability seemingly without his coat and it confused me a little, because I was so sure that him not needing any clothing to use it was established during the jailbreak, like, the portals were not connected to his coat in any place there. Am I going insane and/or not getting something? 😭
I think the confusion comes from the fact we've seen moments where Nikolai visibly hasn't had his cloak on him and him still using his ability, for example when he's disguised. Those moments could be explained by the fact he probably had the cloak hidden under his clothes. Though that then doesn't explain how he did that trick to fake his death during the sunday tragedy where he didn't have his cloak on him. I think how his ability works is that he doesn't necessarily have to be wearing it, just that his cloak is a /literal/ portal (basically his cloak can act as either the exit or entrance for the connection he wants and is also the setpoint for that 30 meter distance he's restricted too, meaning that his ability is to activate his cloak's spatial connection to a pocket dimension so that he can use his cloak to set spatial connections within 30 meters of where the cloak is without having it on him. This is then why he was able to do that trick in the sunday tragedy, get fyozai out of their cells and to hold himself up with that bar by using his ability by taking off his cloak and placing it on the ground (the cloak opened a connection between the area he placed it down in and the area where he's currently holding himself up).
It is exactly as how he said it in that one chapter when we're first explained his ability, he does need his cloak because it's what's connected to that pocket dimension, but he doesn't necessarily have to be wearing it since he never specifies that.
What do you like the most about fyodor? Like what is it that makes you go like "ah this man is Def.. something"
"Like" is probably not the right word for what I'm about to say, but if I would have to pick something it'd be how delusional he is, how not in his right mind he seems to be, it's interesting to speculate how he got to that point and where it will end up leading him. His goal to erase the sin of ability users becomes more intriguing the more the events of the series unfold and the more you learn about the other characters, which makes his goal seem further misguided. I think it's the idea of this infallible person who is actually very flawed deep down is what I find most intriguing
What do you think about how Fyodor seems to know a little too much about abilities compared to other characters? As I said in my previous question - he was able to start a singularity without a problem and steer everything in his favour. But he is also able to communicate and coordinate with his ability even when it is separated from him? How and why does he do so? Does he know sth about abilities we don't?
I was going to bring up Fyodor's weird wealth of knowledge he seems to have in your previous question if I hadn't seen this one. He might know something about abilities that we don't given he seems to weirdly know a lot about Atsushi and his potential connection with the book, and his ability also seems to have weird properties compared to most other abilities (either because his ability has something unique to it that we haven't seen before (which is mostly what I suspect) or that his knowledge of abilities allows him to have that odd connection with his). It's kind of unsurprising that he seems to know so much since his end goal is connected to abilities (and the book) in the first place, so I can imagine maybe after he manifested his own ability he started to learn every thing about them, for many reasons we could speculate. Fyodor remains an enigma.
What do you think about singularities in BSD and how they affect a charecter "humanity" (Chuuya with Arahabaki, Verlaine with his singularity, Dazai with NLH (in Beast he is able to create a singularity with it which I think it really interesting, especially considering the insane nature of NLH an ability) (To add onto that I think it's also interesting how Fyodor was able to start a singularity without any problems or complications in Dead apple through Shibusawa )
If we're thinking about singularities in bsd metaphorically, if abilities in bsd are part of and reflective of the user's soul then I imagine singularities as sort of a manifestation of the user's most intense feelings, bringing out the most intense part of themselves, which then makes them feel less human, or I guess more disconnected from other people, because that ability part of themselves is amplified if that makes sense? (because there is already a separation depicted in the series between those with abilities and those without). They basically become more ability than human, which is what Verlaine and Chuuya were treated as, Shibusawa kind of lost himself after Fyodor activated his singularity, and for Dazai it brought great sorrow because he knew he didn't really have a place in his world.
what was your first impression of fyolai and what made you ship them
It took me a while before I actually started shipping fyolai because at first I didn't care much for Fyodor's character. It kind of took me joining the fandom, and then me taking more interest in Fyodor, for me to start paying attention to their dynamic and then start shipping them. So I guess my first impression of them wasn't really anything remarkable, it was clear to me they both liked each other in their own weird way but at the time I didn't have much interest for them back then. (and I'm not someone who's very crazy into shipping as well so I already didn't have much interest in trying to ship the characters when I first got into bsd except for maybe skk)
I'd invite you, but your inbox on twitter isn't open ~mapface
Wait, invite me to what
hi
Hiiiii
What are you looking forward to the most in bsd s5? :)
If I were to be honest, the mersault and fyolai scenes. Not like I'm not looking forward to anything else though, I am really excited for the whole season.
Whats something about you that would surprise people who knew you?
By 'people who knew you' do you mean like people irl? Because I think they would definitely be surprised if they knew I had an account like this with a decently sized following lol
there’s something i’ve been confused about. fyodor told dazai that he had chuuya deform the door rails in advance, but if you go back to chapter 101 that literally did not happen? you can see both doors close fully and fyodor also seemed to be genuinely surprised and panicked as if he didn’t actually know the flooding was going to happen. i’m going insane no one else has noticed this. am i missing something or did fyodor just Lie about the solution
Don't worry you're not the only one who's noticed! Yes after this chapter and then rereading chapter 101 there is certainly something that feels strange about it. You can't attach images on here so I'll post screenshots on the tweet but yeah it does seem like genuine shock coming from Fyodor. He even panics when he sees that the door's closed and gets Chuuya to try and punch the walls, makes you question why would he be visibly panicked if he supposedly prepared for something like that to happen? I do talk a little about this here as well: https://twitter.com/VannyStarBSD/status/1621547067792400386?s=20&t=t63CGvqFtU_KCBwVjGIFSQ
It is possible that maybe the reason why we don't see the door deformed is that there might've been a continuity error, but his initial panic does seem genuine
If he was lying though, then I'm not sure how else he would've gotten out
Please tell ur opinion on religion
I find religion pretty fascinating. I'm not really a religious person myself (I am agnostic) nor was I raised religious, but I can understand why some people like it and even love it while some feel the opposite. Religion is a very interesting concept to me but overall I'm neutral on it and I don't have anything against people who are religious, just as long as you're not trying to force your beliefs on other people (especially if you're going to do it for arguable immoral reasons).
Retrospring uses Markdown for formatting
*italic text*
for italic text
**bold text**
for bold text
[link](https://example.com)
for link