Retrospring is shutting down on 1st March, 2025 Read more
My name is Youko. I am a fox girl who enjoys playing around and learning new things. Let's be friends! 💖
512
Hii this is the anon that said that likes your vibes...since I'm a priv account I can't interact directly but I can interact on here if that's okay ^^; I'll sign off with 🐺
Aside from that!!!! What do you think about Kohaku and Hiiro...I think they're very silly and sweet
Of course, you're welcome to interact with me using whatever way you're comfortable with ❤️
Kohaku and Hiiro are cute. I love them both. I've been rooting on the friendship since I seriously got into Enstars back in 2021. I'm so happy to see they interact properly as of late. I want Hiiro to have one billion friends.
Hiiro's new casual outfit is cute but I can't help but think that it makes him look like a dad that takes his kids to go fishing at the nearest lake on the weekends. I know that's very specific but that's how I feel about hit fit
Oh god that's funny. You're right. I think his design looks too red when he wears the new fit. Hiiro's fall-winter casual is the cutest thing ever with his little navy sweater vest, so I didn't expect to see an outfit I liked more than that, but I honestly prefer Hiiro's old spring-summer casual to this one.
How do you think Hiiro's relationship with Jun and Izumi will be in TearS?
Hmm... Hiiro will get along with Jun easily. They're both "muscles characters" who bond over a shared interest in physical activity/working out. Izumi on the other hand, I'm not sure. I think Hiiro and Jun could be a breath of fresh air for Izumi who is used to dealing with pushy people in his unit. Hiiro is pushy in his own way, but he's respectful to his seniors and excited to learn from them. I wonder if Tsukasa will somehow be brought up in their conversations, like if Izumi will compare Hiiro to Tsukasa? They have some kind of one-sided rivalry on Tsukasa's end, so I wonder if that could come up. I feel like Hiiro has totally stagnated especially within Alkaloid, so I hope TearS has some kind of real story that does something for him.
Do u think the amagi brother (and by extend Ubuntu) can be saved if they aren’t written by Akira? /genq
I will assume Ubuntu is an autocorrected Ibuki. I'm not sure about Ibuki because we have not seen enough of him yet, but I don't think it's that simple for the Amagis. They've become so fucked up that it's not just a question of getting Akira out of the writing room but bringing in a different really skilled writer who is educated about Indigenous issues, preferably pertaining especially to Ainu people.
Have you ever considered making a Tumblr? I feel like the format would lend itself well to long & in-depth discussions and conversation, and I generally find a lot of the fandom there to be more mature and open-minded then on here, in my personal experience (I made a couple posts shortly after Ibuki's debut just listing the basics of him being Ryukyuan and how that could affect discussion, and the response was pretty thoughtful and positive). I also know a couple finePs in particular that I think would be happy to learn & contribute considering their past posts acknowledging the concerning direction the unit is taking. This isn't trying to pressure you or anything, and I apologize if it comes off that way 😅 I just thought I'd ask because I would love to see you talk about it more + get he convo going on other platforms as well, since I truly do think you'd have a receptive audience and are fantastic at explaining and provoking learning 🫶
Thank you! Tumblr has been suggested to me before. I'm just a creature of habit and prefer to stick with what I know, which is Twitter. I won't even make an Instagram account, much to a few my friends' dismays lol. I don't doubt the fandom on Tumblr is more mature. Maybe I'll join it one day.
hiiii i read your carrd and i just wanted to ask which are the rinne ships you are uncomfortable with. sorry if it's too personal, i just wouldn't want to follow and see hate for a ship i like, or for you to see me in your follows and have to see something you dislike
do you ever see yourself getting out of enstars in the future if (god forbid) ibuki's story gets handled poorly ? genq im super sorry if this is worded weirdly i dont mean any ill intent
It's hard to say. Matrix crushed me really. Like I'll still love Rinne, Hiiro and Niki forever. But my interest in the story waned significantly. Now, I don't have any particular hopes for their stories. Ibuki piqued my interest immediately. I heard Okinawa and instantly grabbed onto him and decided he was going to be my guy. On top of that he is also American, so this was really exciting to me. It felt personal. Japanese American characters with Indigenous backgrounds are not common. I saw the little audition video where Ibuki was being silly and punched the camera and I absolutely knew he was the one. Perhaps this was extremely foolish of me, but we will see. I was disheartened by Ibuki's introductory story, because I found it insensitive. Nonetheless, I already was pretty sure I wanted to produce him at this point. I wasn't ready to commit to saying I loved him yet, though. What we saw from him in the first half of VS Audience revitalized my love for Enstars. I was like "Yep. The trio just became a quartet." Ibuki skyrocketed up the list of characters I love. I am very selective about who I produce, so this was a big deal tbh. Anyways, I've put up with so much bullshit with the Amagis over the years and their OG backstory is so absurdly offensive that it makes you wonder how they could top that. But if the message of the Okinawa arc literally becomes "Colonization is good actually," I'll probably have to draw the line there. It would probably be my breaking point. That said, I can't really leave a hyperfixation until something new comes along, and they tend to last quite a while. My last one was six years I believe. I guess I don't have a fully definitive answer to this question. If Ibuki's story really sucks I'll also start trying to organize and I'll be formally complaining to Happy Elements so they have that to look forward to.
Hey just checking in about this- since the topic has come up regarding the poor writing of the Okinawan arc and portrayal do you have any kind of DNI with certain fans (ie- do you not want FineP or RyuseitaiP following you). Just wanted to make sure I wasn't making you uncomfortable with my presence (RyuseitaiP)
Thanks for checking in with me. I don't have any DNI, and I'm not uncomfortable with Ryuseitai or fine producers. The way the story with Okinawa has been written is not at all the fault of the fans, and I'd never hold it against people who enjoy the units involved with it. My criticisms of the Enstars fandom can be harsh, but that's simply because I believe in people's ability to do better. I welcome anyone on my account who has an open mind and is respectful to different groups of people. I highly encourage a critical reading and informed consumption of Ensemble Stars.
Thoughts on Ibara?
I like Ibara. Eden is one of those units I enjoy but don't produce. He's Eichi's business rival so I like him for that too. Neither of them are very ethical but Eichi is a serious villain while Ibara is just an instigator and thorn in the side (pun fully intended) in stories, imo. Even since before Eichi entered his colonizer arc, I've been rooting for Ibara. My CosPro bias. I appreciate him for taking Rinne in again, even if it was with selfish motivations.
I understand all of the stuff you said about Eichi and his wrongdoing, but I think why Eichi of all "antagonist " is chosen to be this way instead of all the other. For example when mentioning about mischievous and will step on everything to get to the goal, people usually remember Saegusa right? But I'm not sure if I don't read enough stories or all the evil people in Enstars is nothing compared to Eichi beside God Father? Why is an idol like him is chosen to keep being the evil guy, and can his fan enjoy him with all the stuff he has done... (I guess not)
Eichi wants to grow ES because it's his company, his childish fantasy that he will stop at nothing to obtain. Ibara is ruthless and a tactician, but he isn't delusional and idealistic like Eichi. Eichi pictures what he wants and starts slashing down everything in his way to get there. He uses the corpses of the people he has crushed like a staircase in hopes he will one day climb high enough to achieve his personal dream world. That's why he is doing these things. The other thing is, Eichi has been somewhat flippant about preservation of and respect for cultures for a while. He once said to Keito that he would burn down the Buddhist temples. Obviously, this didn't happen, but it's a cruel threat he made because he knows Keito is Buddhist and that the religion is important to him. Oh, and lastly, I'm not a fine-p, but I've heard from a friend that even Wataru is growing frustrated with Eichi's stagnation. In other words, the writers are self-aware. They know what they are doing.
i'm fairly new to enstars (been here for like a year and am already incredibly burnout) so hmmm i'm kind of disappointed that people didn't care about the way the amagis were treated, but i guess it's not surprising considering that. i feel like the way hiiro gets treated in stories is still extremely under-discussed in fandom. to a surprising degree, because i remember searching up my annoyances and seeing nothing. and this isn't even the aira stuff, i mean stuff like the ox legend story. it's strange that enstars is technically wrapped up in so many sociopolitical themes yet no one wants to examine them. and i get that it's not done well per se but still, isn't it worth acknowledging? okay i think i should stop 🤐 i do not want people to attack you for shit /IM/ saying
(and yeah... i'm glad you find the ryst lore bit amusing, but i've seen multiple people do this and it irritates me. why does our engagement start and end with something being somehow related to fictional work, which evidently is filled with biases. what's the point of educating yourself if it's not going to broaden your understanding of how biases may influence how something is portrayed, and whether that's a good thing or not. who do these beliefs benefit? does it tell us something about society? and if these thoughts are enabled, who does it affect? what are the repercussions of that? critical thinking!!! it's important!!! fiction doesn't exist in a vacuum. it's made by real people, and guess what... these people are not apolitical, everything is tinged by politics whether you think so or not)
You are not alone in your grievances about Hiiro's treatment, believe me. I have an entire video essay in the works about the Amagis as Ainu characters, and the issues with Hiiro definitely get worse than microaggressions in the text. I could go on a long rant about the many ways the writers' biases shine through the story. But I'll save it for when that time comes.
Don't worry about people attacking me. I don't expect anyone would because I haven't said anything particularly unreasonable or inflammatory. I was harsh on Ryuseitai and fine fans who neglected to read up on Okinawa until now, but they can probably take the heat. Besides, it's never too late to start educating yourself. People mapping out lore and trying to lead discussions while conveniently leaving out the glaring politics of this story has started to bug me. But what really annoys me is when such a person starts to flounder and give a half-assed or performative response to being questioned about it. Ultimately, I respect the work being done by these individuals. They're clearly putting time and heart into it, there's no doubt about that. It's nice of them to try and assemble the plot for people in an easy to digest format. But I can't say I respect the manner in which it's being done, or all of their behavior. Sorry for being abrasive about this, but also not really sorry. Bleh 😝 You see, like I've said before, I see Ryukyuan people as my siblings. And, to be transparent, I have discussed the story of Ensemble Stars with my Ryukyuan friends because I wanted to hear their opinions. Recently, I phoned one of them up and we chatted about the things I've been seeing on social media in regards to the subject. Obviously, I don't speak for my friends or anyone else but myself. Still, I want to be clear, this outrage is not simply my own. I know at least some real Ryukyuan people have found the story and people's responses concerning. I wouldn't be acting with such conviction if this wasn't the case. By the way, since last time people didn't listen, I'm gonna reiterate this. If you think you know the Enstars fans I'm referring to here, don't go after them. Don't send them anons. Seriously, I mean it. I just strongly believe that if they want to guide people through the Okinawa Arc, if they want to understand the story they are reading for themselves, they better start giving it the deep thought it demands. Ultimately, Enstars is steeped in political commentary. People are fine talking about how it criticizes the idol industry, for example. So don't clam up when it's time to talk about the really uncomfortable stuff. I understand it's hard. Intimidating. You don't want to step on anyone's toes. My frustrated outburst a little while back probably didn't help that atmosphere, so I apologize. I'm hoping, going forward, I can instead foster a better environment where people are comfortable to talk about Okinawa and Ensemble Stars. That's what I want in the end, for people to talk. And to do it genuinely, not just for show.
returning anon, but ahhhh thank you... i'm glad to be validated even if it feels silly. because the lack of conversations around these subjects genuinely makes me so confused. i'm used to fandoms viewing critical thinking as an inherently bad thing, but i've never come across fans so averse to examining real life implications of what text may mean until i became a fan of enstars. like for example, people can write essays about eichi's psyche or whatever, but when it comes to what his actions contextually mean within a broader scope no one ever wants to talk about that and i find it odd. i don't hold it against people for liking certain characters, but the lack of conversation genuinely confuses me. when that fairytale event came out, i was genuinely shocked how little people raised concerns over project atlantis. granted, a lot of it is shoved into stella marris and iirc atlantis doesn't really cover it, but still... you would think it would make greater waves in fandom, considering how upset people were with amagis treatment (which is a good thing!!!). and yet, people were excited for tori to continue project atlantis... which somehow feels ironic, considering even he thought eichi's behavior was gross in stella maris.
anyway i guess my point is just i wish people would treat these subject matters far more delicately instead of like fun little detours to deepen their understanding of their enstars favs. like no, this is not fun ryuseitai lore. you are engaging with real life history that STILL EXISTS and AFFECTS people to this day. once you learn that, anything enstars has written in relation to okinawa (or colonization) becomes horrifying. it's not fun. it's awful to read about and experience as an audience, especially with how little seriousness the subject gets approached at the end of the day. or at least that's how i feel i guess
It is really uncomfortable to me that it has taken this long for people in the fandom to talk about the Okinawa Arc critically or show interest in learning about the history of the Ryukyu Islands, and it's still hardly even the bare-minimum. Especially a sentiment I saw that the introduction of Ibuki is what facilitates looking into this. This might offend some people, but I beg to disagree. The moment it became clear Okinawa is a place of significance to the Ensemble Stars plot, fans should have taken the time to start educating themselves. Especially Ryuseitai fans and fine fans. This pertains to your favorite characters. What took so long? I'm happy to see people are taking the steps to do this now, but really. Come on. You have to be reminded to do it? Do you even care about the story you're reading (assuming you're keeping up)? Yes, I'm being harsh about this. The same way we have had to be harsh about the Amagis. I'll make a racket. Which, you mention fans care about how Rinne and Hiiro are treated. I will let you know, this is a development in the past two years that started on Twitter because of some provocative posts challenging the way people approach them. Giving a shit about the Amagis was not an inherent quality this fandom had. It was pushed on them. And I'm gonna push the Okinawa business on them, too. You're all gonna be hearing from me about it for a while. I don't call myself the world's most annoying for nothing. Youko is diving right into this subject! I'm a Japanese history student at a famously woke university and I just so happen study under someone who specializes in Okinawa's history. So bring it on Enstars fandom. Let's pick apart what we're dealing with here in the writing.
Different anon, but I agree. I saw someone a while back make a post along the lines of Enstarries refusing to acknowledge characters that weren't involved in The War, but it's insane that it goes so far to ignore the actually horrific things Eichi is doing NOW in the story in favour of talking about a story arc that happened years ago and does not matter to the current story. Enstarries really need to get over the War and actually pay attention to stories taking place in the current era. They've had 9 years to discuss that old story and its ramifications, when are they finally going to look at the clearly worse problems Eichi is enacting now? It's to the point that I personally can't see anything redeeming in Eichi as a character, but idk if that's me being too harsh (I don't think it is)
YEP, ALL THIS. The War is still very important to understand many of the characters but the writers have moved on. Eichi is quite something, isn't he! Akira talked about introducing Gate Keeper because he needed an antagonist who was a step above Eichi in intimidation factor. That step above turned out to be a cartoony evil thug that just made a bunch of bluffs about killing people. Eichi saw that and said "The Emperor must reclaim his evil throne."
WAIT IM SORRY ABOUT THE ASK I SENT I DIDNT REALIZE YOU GOT INTO A DEBATE? ARGUMENT OVER SOMETHING SIMILAR SOME DAYS AGO... i'm sorry 😭 what an unfortunate coincidence. i just saw one of ur tweets in passing some days ago and it's been weighing on my mind a bit, especially with the lack of critical discussions in this fanbase. this whole subject has been bothering me ever since i read stella marris but the the fact that no one ever talks about it just kind of bothers me. sorry i didn't know people got pissy with you 💔
Retrospring uses Markdown for formatting
*italic text*
for italic text
**bold text**
for bold text
[link](https://example.com)
for link