FOR HATS:
nate - nothing super specific, likes Big Fancy ones because they catch the eye, likes the one with feathers or cool patterns
venus - a nice trilby or breton hat, he likes it classy (though he has a soft spot for top hats because he already kind of leans into a magician vibe)
nate - can't stand hats and would prefer hoodies
lake - bowler hat (would get trilby to match with venus)

FOR SHOES
niel - boots in general! he likes big long boots, good for stomping, they feel Significant
venus - dress shoes, knee-high boots with heels, laced shoes
nate - timberlands, work boots or shoes that generally can bear a lot of wear and tear, he doesn't care a lot about the look of them
lake - honestly loves kitten heels and scorpion heels, but generally wears dress shoes as per the butler look