Retrospring is shutting down on 1st March, 2025 Read more
512
Which is a manga spread that left you speechless when you first saw it?
Roger laughing from One Piece feels like the easy go-to. Just sort of gave me goosebumps the first time I read it. That said, some of the spreads in the final chapters of Fire Punch left me pretty in awe (granted, in completely the opposite sort of way)
What would be your go-to watch order for someone to catch up with Star Wars now? I'm thinking of getting into it but there's so many movies and TV shows at this point.
Really depends what you mean by 'catch up'. How much of a completionist are you? By and large, release order is a safe bet. If you're thinking purely in terms of the current, ongoing saga with the Mandalorian, I'd probably say something along the lines of
Original Trilogy (A New Hope, Empire Strikes Back, Return of the Jedi, films IV-VI)
Prequel Trilogy (Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones, Revenge of the Sith, films I-III)
Star Wars: The Clone Wars (the CGI series, specifically)
The Mandalorian, seasons 1 and 2
Star Wars: Rebels
The Book of Boba Fett
The Mandalorian season 3
And then the upcoming Ahsoka series will probably be best watched next, though that isn't out yet.
You can kind of do Rebels and Mandalorian S2 in either order, Rebels comes first release-wise and chronologically but you're hopping around the timeline anyway, and I think Mando S2 serves as a pretty solid re-entry for the character the two series' share. I watched them in this order, and it piqued my interest as to what that character had been up to between here and Clone Wars, which Rebels answers.
Watchu watching, reading and playing atm?
rn I'm mainly watching Hajime no Ippo on my commutes since it dropped on my region's Netflix recently. At home I've got Samurai Jack, Our Flag Means Death and Hunter x Hunter on the go but not making huge amounts of progress through them.
Manga-wise, obvs there's Sket Dance, which I aim to finish at...some point in the next year lol. It's long for its genre and very dense text-wise. Also keeping up with One Piece, World Trigger and Chainsaw Man, but I like to keep my series' I follow chapter-to-chapter sparse.
Games-wise I've jumped from Breath of the Wild to Age of Calamity. I think I'm ready for another Warriors game to veg out to in a way I wasn't when it first came out. Also got loads of other games on the backburner (I mean, who hasn't lol) but the ones I seem to dip into the most are Celeste and Luigi's Mansion 3.
What do you think makes a good video game adaptation?
Capturing the narrative experience the player feels through gameplay without said gameplay present. Obviously there's no one-size fits all answer, but I think this can apply to a lot of them. Faithfulness alone isn't always enough.
As case studies, Danganronpa the Animation and the respective Persona 4 and 5 anime very faithfully recreate the plot of their games, but utterly fail to realise the experience of them. I remember watching DGR before playing the game and finding something really...off about how the cast investigate the various murders. There's just these extended, inert sequences of the characters spotting clues with no commentary on them, and then during the class trial Naegi just effortlessly strings all the clues together. There's a reason this rings so hollow- this is not how it feels to solve the mystery in Danganronpa games. As you're collecting each clue, you'll start speculating as to how they're relevent, and this deductive process continues throughout the trial. Compare this to any other detective story- there is always a strong sense of logical continuity. Detective Conan solves this problem by giving Conan a consistent interior monologue throughout the investigation of each case. If you're not involved in the deductive process, it just feels like watching a strategy guide.
Persona 5 the Animation bothered me for a different reason. I watched up to the end of Kamoshida's palace. For one, Amamiya is presented as a silent self-insert, rather than trying to embellish his personality based on Joker's more sassy dialogue options. The other is how...pointless the palaces feel. The dungeon-crawling experience is the challenge the Phantom Thieves take on. The arduous struggle of making your way through a complex labyrinth of enemies. And here they just get in and rush straight to the end to take on the boss, any exploration is skipped over. The plot of the game is stripped down to its cliffnotes and set-pieces, and as a result, nothing feels like it matters. Truth be told, I'm not sure an ideal anime adaptation of this could exist as things stand. The anime industry is moving to increasingly short-form productions and my blue sky pitch for a Persona adaptation would be a 50+ episode affair. For the palaces, particularly the early ones, I'd spent several episodes on the thieves getting to grips with the unique challenges each ones pose and the tougher fights they'd find with in. This isn't even getting into how you lace in the Confidants which...honestly, I'm not sure even translates mediums. idk how you present those in anime form without completely killing the pace dead in repetitive, intrusive ways. Anyway, I've gotten quite thoroughly away from the question at this point but I'll take any excuse to ramble, thanks.
Got an any anime hot takes?
Recap episodes and/or compilation movies, are good actually, and I'd be happy if there were more of them. They're usually not a replacement for a first-time viewing, but if you want to catch up on a series you've already enjoyed for a new installment but you've forgotten a bunch of it? Super handy way to get up to speed in a time efficient way. Especially with how much new media is churned out to us these days.
what are you watching on the go lately? still on dat Doctor Who streak?
right now I'm watching Six Feet Under, an HBO drama about a dysfunctional family that run a funeralcare service.
it's a very thoughtful and absorbing watch! As each of the characters goes through various life struggles, they take turns having to be either the emotional or career support in a way that feels very true to life.
I might check out House of the Dragon afterwards since it's on the same streaming app and people seem very high on it
Doctor Who-wise, I caught up to where my girlfriends were in their own Classic who watchthrough a while ago and we've been slowly making our way through Troughton's run.
Who is your favourite artist?
don't have a fixed overall fave but music-wise I've been enjoying a lot of Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young.
art-wise, there's a few on twitter I've been digging a bunch lately.
@/sksn_herb has some great Pokemon gen III stuff of the two trainer characters (I think inspired by the Adventures manga but I've not read that far yet!)
@/tiredhomeboi does a lot of very cute Hunter x Hunter stuff, particularly of Kurapika
@/Rejuvo is nice for very stylised characters through angular shapes and does stuff with characters from all sorts (One Piece, Lord of the Rings etc)
Do your friends like you the way you are?
I'll get back to you when I've built a mind-reading device, anon
If you had infinite time, is there a game you would like to play through or complete that you wouldn't otherwise?
Final Fantasy XIV. I will never ever have time for that game even though loads of my friends agree it's great. I'd just rather spend that time playing other JRPG's tbh!
Rank every Doctor's opening episode you've seen on DW
Okay, least fave to best
Deep Breath (Capaldi) is the weakest to me from memory. I recall it just felt a bit...messy and weird? Wasn't really into the amount of comments Clara made about 12's age
Rose (Eccleston) comes up second last. I recall the episode being structurally fine and a decent enough way to reintroduce the series, but a bit lacklustre on the whole. The effects have aged...poorly.
An Unearthly Child (Hartnell) has a strong hook and establishes a lot of intrigue around 1, Susan and the TARDIS. Not the most substantial and leads into a pretty sluggish arc with the cavemen but a good opener!
The Christmas Invasion (Tennant) is pure mid-2000's BBC cheese and I love it. It's such a silly, fun way to introduce 10. The swordfight in a dressing gown and Harriet Jones' betrayal at the end are particular highlights
The Woman Who Fell to Earth (Whittaker) - Love the way this episode puts emphasis on the local community surrounding the new companions pitching in together to stop the alien threat. A really strong tone-setter that instantly sets 13's era apart from what came before. A darker, cinematic more grounded feel was exactly the change of tact the series needed (whether the rest followed through or not)
The Eleventh Hour (Smith) - There's a case to be made that this should be number 1. A really well-structured relaunch that delves into how an unfocused, reacclimating Doctor can effect his relationship with a companion through time travel. 11 is easily at his most likeable in season 5 and this ep does a great job getting you on board with him
The Power of the Daleks (Troughton) - it perhaps has an advantage being the only entry here with the benefit of a full serial's run...but damn this one is good. The first time the Daleks are really explored as a unique threat. The slow build-up of their machinations work in tandem with everyone's lack of trust in a new Doctor who's yet to prove himself. It's a perfect opening trial for 2's deceptively unnassuming schemer.
Looking forward to updating these when I've seen more Doctors!
Fave of the main Don't Hug Me I'm Scared trio?
Tough, but gotta go with Red Guy. I love his chill unassuming voice. Also it tickles me that he's typically the most aloof around the other residents, but whenever he's with other Red Guys a giddy overly-eager side of him emerges.
Do your friends know too much about your hobbies?
Any that follow me on twitter, perhaps! Depends how much of what I post that they take on board really 😂
Fave anime ending theme ever?
Tie between Minna no Peace from Gurren Lagann and Hyori Ittai from Hunter x Hunter. They're both just...flawless. Absolute bangers
Are Mother 1 and Earthbound required playing before Mother 3?
Earthbound yes, Mother no. Earthbound/Mother 2 is pretty much a remake of Mother, with basically no direct callbacks to the events of the first game, and is much more accessible gameplay-wise. It also features the more distinctive atmophere and quirkiness that the series is known for.
Mother 3 on the other hand is a direct follow-up to 2 that iterates on what it does. Having seen lets plays of all 3 I'd planned to skip straight to it but now I feel that'd be a mistake. Earthbound is impeccably well-structured with a unique, delightful tone to it that should not be missed, and does a much better job of feeding you its mechanics in manageable chunks.
EB is a mostly cohesive journey where you acquire new party members and PSI abilities (spells, basically) at a steady rate. Mother 3, on the other hand, spends its first act jumping between player characters in service in service of a more narrative-driven game, before eventually giving you a full party to work with. But then once you have this full party, the game gives you new spells at a much faster rate to make up for lost time. As a result people familiar with Earthbound are much less likely to be overwhelmed.
It's beneficial from a story and mechanical standpoint to play Earthbound first.
Best Yu Yu Hakusho girl?
Toughie tbh, Shizuru's my fave in terms of design and outward personality, tho Botan's just so fun and well written throughout, especially in the dub. So many incidental gags and one liners that got a huge chuckle out of me
Retrospring uses Markdown for formatting
*italic text*
for italic text
**bold text**
for bold text
[link](https://example.com)
for link