Eddy and Trent would not perform very well. Both are bad at lying and don't handle the pressure well. Trent especially would detest the game altogether.

Darrell would perform well until he inevitably blunders some information that's a dead give away he's a bad guy. He would try to be very competitive though.

Vin would be very similar to Darrell, except Vin would be much less competitive.

Cliff would do pretty well. He's good at traitor games. He'd do his best to win (fair-in-square) despite not being the best at deception. He's good under pressure (at least externally).

Pat would take the game a little too seriously and scare people with how well he can lie and manipulate information.

Chester would be the opposite of Pat. He has the capacity to perform very well as a bad guy, but he'd choose to hold back.

Dave would play along but not take the game too seriously. He's there for fun and wouldn't be too competitive.

Corey would be cool as a cucumber and also be very good at playing the bad guy. He's not afraid to use his natural charm to his advantage.

Skizzy is frighteningly good at these kinds of games. That said, he'd have some trouble playing as the good guy since a lot of people would assume he's bad guy more often than not.

April would not do well. She would get frustrated quickly when people start distrusting her, which would be a dead giveaway.

Moriah would be a silent assassin. When she plays the game as good or bad guy, she'll be extremely friendly to other players, exploiting their trust.

Hayley would be quite good at these games as the bad guy. She'd choose a more strategic than manipulative approach. She'd play the same way as good guy, so it'd be hard to get a read on her.