ooh okay

sonny: rocky road cuz hes sweet but as a little bit of a crunch (his bad boy side (mental illness))

brett: strawberry frozen yogurt! sweet and adorable aaaand hes strawberry blonde so it fits hehe. does tonsss of toppings

JR: hes a real classy guy so probably something like coffee or pecan bourbon

chris: feels like a pistachio kinda guy. i feel like that might be canon but maybe im making that up lmfao