Retrospring is shutting down on 1st March, 2025 Read more

Anon X) · 9mo

Hi hi cherry, I saw your answer to this one ask about prisoners dying and I wanted to add my two cents. I personally feel like characters dying would have more than just shock value. One of the core aspect of the series (imho) is how it's a social experiment, meaning that We as an audience and how we react to the events play a huge role in what makes the series what it is. What I'm trying to get at is how, the narrative itself had warned us about events that Will Likely happen if we vote certain ways (Haruka if Mu guilty, Amane if She & Shidou inno which might affect Mahiru) and people decided to ignore them. It'd just put a Lot of Weight behind our actions if the writers decided to go through with what they had warned us, basically subjecting the audience to more than just shock but also guilt and a sense of "dread" over how to vote in the final rounds, and all of this will especially impact Es as a character, since they represent us, and how they interact with the rest of the prisoners.

But a random other thing I've been thinking about is what actually happens when characters Die, because Milgram doesn't really follow Real World logic. When I checked what Jackalope said about how Mahiru would've died, he used the word "Lost" and I found it to be a pretty... interesting way to refer to death. I'm spitballing here without any evidence but what if even if characters die we still have "leftovers" of them, we still get their songs...etc but we can only "bring them back to life" if we vote them Innocent.

MM yeah I get that, I said something like that in my ask and I don't think the characters dying would be purely for shock value, but if they are throwing away the rest of the characters development & story just to kill them off, even if it is to show us our actions really do have an impact like that, it is still partially for a shock reaction. Like they would want us to be shocked that our actions could do something like that...and even if they didn't want it to be for shock value it's a really horrible way to end a characters arc. I guess it could be like "your decisions decide whether you get to see the end of their growth & story" but that feels a bit cheap, personally. I understand where they would be coming from with it though.

I like that idea though if a character does end up dying! I think I would rather their ghost be there & everyone not acknowledging them as dead, because then we would still get t3 character growth therefore we would have a proper song and vd. But that would be a whole ordeal because then we wouldnt know about the "bringing them back to life" because we dont really know that they are dead...it'd be pretty complicated to pull off where we still get to have the character they would've been in t3, which is why I'm not a huge fan of getting their story after they died

Retrospring uses Markdown for formatting

*italic text* for italic text

**bold text** for bold text

[link](https://example.com) for link